Indonesia: Could the 1997 crisis return? Sovereign creditworthiness under pressure | Insight Out (Dr. Choi Jun-young, Yulchon)
An independent exercise, not a statement by the video creator or verification of every claim in the video.
A local share-price gain can still mean a loss in won
For an unhedged hypothetical holding over the same period, a 20% equity gain in rupiah and a 20% fall in the rupiah’s won-denominated value change an initial 100 into 100×1.20×0.80=96, a return of −4%. Simply adding the returns to obtain 0% is incorrect. A 15% currency-value decline instead gives 100×1.20×0.85=102, a won return of 2%; with a 20% equity gain, the break-even decline in the currency’s value is about 16.67%.
Check for yourself
- Is the exchange rate quoted as the rupiah’s value in won or the won’s value in rupiah?
- Do the equity return and currency move cover the same holding period, and can the position actually be sold and converted?
Limits of application
These are unitless hypothetical prices, not forecasts for Indonesian equities or exchange rates. Dividends, taxes, trading and conversion costs, transfer restrictions, bid-ask spreads and hedging costs are excluded; inadequate liquidity may prevent execution at the calculated price.
- What to look for
- Examine how equity, currency and market-access risks can rise even in a growing economy through the Indonesian discussion.
- Why it matters
- Separate the meanings of rating outlooks, index reclassification and external balances, and avoid assuming that a large price decline establishes greater recoverable value.
Timeline
5 segmentsMSCI’s official announcement concerns a consultation on moving Indonesia from Emerging Market to Standalone Market status, rather than an already finalized change. It flags opaque ownership and suspected coordinated trading without proving manipulation in every stock; announced reforms must also be distinguished from sustained implementation. Reclassification could change demand from funds tracking the affected indexes, but does not automatically determine a complete exit by all foreign investors or the magnitude of a price decline.
