After real property prices surge, how long until a 10% correction from the observed peak?
Japan, Korea, United States and China · Annual +10% signal → 10% correction
Same conditions, different outcomes
United States · 2021 Q2 · Real-price surge signal · End unconfirmedEnd unconfirmed · 2021 Q2—
- Country and data-definition segment
- United States · Existing-home prices; domestic input series seasonally adjusted
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 2021 Q2
- Peak updated during observation
- 2024 Q4 · 161.0769
- Real-price index at entry
- 149.5667
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- Not confirmed
- Last comparable quarter
- 2026 Q1
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
The exit condition was not confirmed at the observed price of 156.4275 through 2026 Q1. The actual subsequent end is unknown, and the duration is not extended to the verification date, 2026-10-09. This concerns the real index in the relevant United States data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · United States ↗BIS; Federal Reserve based on CoreLogic data; National Association of Realtors · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.US.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1975 Q4–2026 Q1; national sources: Federal Reserve based on CoreLogic data; National Association of Realtors
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
United States · 2004 Q1 · Real-price surge signalCompleted · 2004 Q114 quarters
- Country and data-definition segment
- United States · Existing-home prices; domestic input series seasonally adjusted
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 2004 Q1
- Peak updated during observation
- 2006 Q1 · 153.9192
- Real-price index at entry
- 125.6861
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- 2007 Q3
- Last comparable quarter
- 2026 Q1
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
The difference from 2004 Q1 to 2007 Q3 is 14 quarters. These are boundaries identified from quarterly average indices, not actual events on the first day of a quarter. This concerns the real index in the relevant United States data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · United States ↗BIS; Federal Reserve based on CoreLogic data; National Association of Realtors · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.US.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1975 Q4–2026 Q1; national sources: Federal Reserve based on CoreLogic data; National Association of Realtors
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
Korea · 2002 Q1 · Real-price surge signalCompleted · 2002 Q185 quarters
- Country and data-definition segment
- Korea · Existing-home prices
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 2002 Q1
- Peak updated during observation
- 2021 Q4 · 126.1450
- Real-price index at entry
- 89.4399
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- 2023 Q2
- Last comparable quarter
- 2026 Q1
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
The difference from 2002 Q1 to 2023 Q2 is 85 quarters. These are boundaries identified from quarterly average indices, not actual events on the first day of a quarter. This concerns the real index in the relevant Korea data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. Nationwide existing-home and historical land indicators are used, so this cannot be interpreted as claiming that the nominal price of an individual Seoul apartment has not recovered. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · Korea ↗BIS; Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.KR.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1986 Q1–2026 Q1; national sources: Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
Japan · 1990 Q2 · Real-price surge signalCompleted · 1990 Q211 quarters
- Country and data-definition segment
- Japan · Urban residential land prices
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 1990 Q2
- Peak updated during observation
- 1991 Q1 · 189.2763
- Real-price index at entry
- 182.8323
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- 1993 Q1
- Last comparable quarter
- 2008 Q1
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
The difference from 1990 Q2 to 1993 Q1 is 11 quarters. These are boundaries identified from quarterly average indices, not actual events on the first day of a quarter. This concerns the real index in the relevant Japan data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · Japan ↗BIS; Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism; Japan Real Estate Institute · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.JP.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1955 Q1–2008 Q1; national sources: Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism; Japan Real Estate Institute
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
Korea · 1988 Q3 · Real-price surge signalCompleted · 1988 Q314 quarters
- Country and data-definition segment
- Korea · Existing-home prices
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 1988 Q3
- Peak updated during observation
- 1991 Q2 · 151.2834
- Real-price index at entry
- 127.6467
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- 1992 Q1
- Last comparable quarter
- 2026 Q1
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
The difference from 1988 Q3 to 1992 Q1 is 14 quarters. These are boundaries identified from quarterly average indices, not actual events on the first day of a quarter. This concerns the real index in the relevant Korea data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. Nationwide existing-home and historical land indicators are used, so this cannot be interpreted as claiming that the nominal price of an individual Seoul apartment has not recovered. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · Korea ↗BIS; Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.KR.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1986 Q1–2026 Q1; national sources: Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
Korea · 1983 Q1 · Real-price surge signal · Tracking stopped at a data-definition transitionEnd unconfirmed · 1983 Q1—
- Country and data-definition segment
- Korea · Residential and non-residential land prices
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 1983 Q1
- Peak updated during observation
- 1985 Q4 · 115.3227
- Real-price index at entry
- 93.5724
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- Not confirmed
- Last comparable quarter
- 1985 Q4
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Peak comparisons discontinued after changes in data definitions, such as land versus housing
Data definitions change after 1985 Q4, so peaks and recovery status cannot be compared for the same underlying asset coverage. The case is retained as one without a confirmed end in the prior data segment; it is not asserted to have remained unrecovered afterward or through the present. Elapsed duration is not provided. This concerns the real index in the relevant Korea data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. Nationwide existing-home and historical land indicators are used, so this cannot be interpreted as claiming that the nominal price of an individual Seoul apartment has not recovered. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · Korea ↗BIS; Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.KR.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1975 Q1–1985 Q4; national sources: Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
United States · 1977 Q3 · Real-price surge signalCompleted · 1977 Q320 quarters
- Country and data-definition segment
- United States · Existing-home prices; domestic input series seasonally adjusted
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 1977 Q3
- Peak updated during observation
- 1979 Q4 · 82.2821
- Real-price index at entry
- 73.3638
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- 1982 Q3
- Last comparable quarter
- 2026 Q1
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
The difference from 1977 Q3 to 1982 Q3 is 20 quarters. These are boundaries identified from quarterly average indices, not actual events on the first day of a quarter. This concerns the real index in the relevant United States data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · United States ↗BIS; Federal Reserve based on CoreLogic data; National Association of Realtors · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.US.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1975 Q4–2026 Q1; national sources: Federal Reserve based on CoreLogic data; National Association of Realtors
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
Korea · 1976 Q1 · Real-price surge signal · Starting boundary uncertainExcluded · 1976 Q1—
Exclusion reason: The first calculable annual growth rate in this segment was already at least 10%, so the actual entry quarter cannot be identified.
- Country and data-definition segment
- Korea · Residential and non-residential land prices
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 1976 Q1
- Peak updated during observation
- 1978 Q3 · 119.1278
- Real-price index at entry
- 69.9412
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- 1980 Q1
- Last comparable quarter
- 1985 Q4
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
Insufficient signal and peak history at the observation-start boundary excludes this case from final-duration statistics and observation counts. This concerns the real index in the relevant Korea data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. Nationwide existing-home and historical land indicators are used, so this cannot be interpreted as claiming that the nominal price of an individual Seoul apartment has not recovered. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · Korea ↗BIS; Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.KR.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1975 Q1–1985 Q4; national sources: Kookmin Bank in Korea; Korea Appraisal Board
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
Japan · 1956 Q1 · Real-price surge signal · Starting boundary uncertainExcluded · 1956 Q1—
Exclusion reason: The first calculable annual growth rate in this segment was already at least 10%, so the actual entry quarter cannot be identified.
- Country and data-definition segment
- Japan · Urban residential land prices
- Signal confirmation quarter
- 1956 Q1
- Peak updated during observation
- 1973 Q3 · 153.1654
- Real-price index at entry
- 14.5879
- Quarter confirming the exit criterion
- 1974 Q3
- Last comparable quarter
- 2008 Q1
- Treatment of subsequent data
- Prices and exit status after this quarter are not estimated
Insufficient signal and peak history at the observation-start boundary excludes this case from final-duration statistics and observation counts. This concerns the real index in the relevant Japan data segment, not recovery of an individual home’s nominal price or invested principal. This is the period waiting for the exit condition after entry, not a claim that annual 10% increases or a bubble persisted throughout.
- BIS Real Residential Property Prices · Japan ↗BIS; Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism; Japan Real Estate Institute · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS Q.JP.R.628; real index2010=100, deflated by CPI; comparison segment 1955 Q1–2008 Q1; national sources: Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism; Japan Real Estate Institute
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
How to interpret this
This is the history from observation of a price-surge signal until confirmation of the correction condition. Spells without corrections and those untrackable after data-definition changes are also retained. Completed-sample averages cannot establish that a surge must be followed by a collapse.
These are fixed price rules for examining bubble and overheating risks, not officially diagnosed bubbles. This fixed sample of 4 countries—Japan, Korea, the United States and China—does not represent all of Asia or the world. The real index divides nominal housing prices by CPI; it differs from investment returns incorporating inflation, housing costs and rents, leverage, taxes and transaction costs. Differences in asset coverage, seasonal adjustment and data starting dates make direct cross-country level comparisons difficult. Historical BIS data may contain quarterly interpolations of annual source data and revisions in the current vintage. This is not a trading strategy recreating signals actually published at the time. Averages limited to completed cases omit long-running unended cases, and statistical independence across countries and periods is not guaranteed. This Korean reprocessed analysis is neither an official BIS translation nor an approved result of BIS or national statistical agencies. Users are not charged additional fees for the included BIS statistics.
Conditions, methodology and sources
Condition: entry occurs in the first quarter when annual real-price growth within the same data-definition segment crosses from below 10% to at least 10%. Exit occurs when the first quarter at least 10% below the highest index observed since entry is confirmed. The full original quarterly history is used, but tracking stops at official data-definition transitions in Japan 2008Q2, Korea 1986Q1, United States 1975Q4 and China 2016Q1; peaks and annual growth rates are recalculated. Only one case is open at a time per country and data segment; overlapping entries during that case are recorded in audit data but not counted as separate cases. Entry dates are not selected using future prices or future peaks. The criteria—annual 10% growth and a 10% decline from the peak—were fixed before reviewing outcomes and are not official bubble thresholds. Annual growth is calculated only against the value 4 quarters earlier within the same definition segment; if the first calculable value already exceeds the threshold, the case is excluded for an uncertain starting boundary. Recovery is not asserted across data gaps or definition transitions, and unconfirmed cases are retained. Quarter labels refer to source observation quarters; day 1 in months 1, 4, 7 and 10 is a storage normalization. Completed duration is the difference in observation-quarter numbers, not a transition time measured by month or day. Each case’s reference date is the end of the last comparable data quarter; the source verification date is 2026-10-09. Reported peaks are updated sequentially using only values observed by that point.
- BIS Selected Residential Property Prices · compilation and national sources ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · 2026-07-31 version; CPI deflation and quarterly observations; historical interpolation warning; source breaks JP2008Q2/KR1986Q1/US1975Q4/CN2016Q1
- BIS Terms of permitted use of statistics ↗Bank for International Settlements (BIS) · Checked 2026-10-09 · BIS attribution; unofficial-translation disclosure; no misleading endorsement; no additional charge to users for included statistics